Spanish researchers have carried out a study to look at the ability of sea urchins (Paracentrotus lividus) generalist herbivores that live in the Mediterranean to limit the invasion of two introduced seaweeds (Lophocladia lallemandii and Caulerpa racemosa), which are having a "grave" effect on the seabed.
Emma Cebrin, lead author of the study and a researcher in the Department of Environmental Sciences at the University of Girona, comments: "After seven months of experimentation, we found that predation by these herbivores had no effect once Caulerpa racemosa was completely established, although it did reduce the degree to which it became established in the very early stages of invasion."
In the case of Lophocladia lallemandii, the sea urchins were able to limit the seasonal spread of the seaweed.
"Since the amount of this species directly consumed by the sea urchins is very low, this reduction was due more to the decline in other native species (consumed by the sea urchins), which act as a substrate for the seaweed," Ms Cebrin explains.
The research, which has been published in Biological Invasions, shows that, although high sea urchin densities can have a limiting effect on the establishment of invasive seaweeds, "they exert no control whatsoever in highly invaded areas," Ms Cebrin adds.
Sea urchins on the attackThe researchers used the experiment to compare the proportion of invasive seaweeds in the environment and the amount actually consumed (present in sea urchin stomach contents).
"The sea urchins do not consume the invasive species according to their availability they have preferences," says Ms Cebrin.
Although the two species of invasive seaweed are very abundant in the environment, "Lophocladia lallemandii was consumed to a very low degree, while the sea urchins displayed a certain preference for eating Caulerpa racemosa."
To find out whether consumption by the sea urchins could control the invasion by these two species, the team of researchers placed large numbers of sea urchins into cages (12 sea urchins/m2) and monitored how the invasive seaweeds developed.
The cages were placed in areas completely invaded by C. racemosa (established invasion), in areas where the invasion was still very limited (initial stages of invasion) and in places where L. lallemandii was very abundant.
"The sea urchins only controlled the expansion of C. racemosa in the cages in places where the invasion was still at a very early stage," Ms Cebrin points out.
The research team says it would "be of great interest" to study possible mechanisms for controlling these invasions, and the resistance of native communities to them, given the growing impact of exotic species.
Ms Cebrin's work, titled "Do native herbivores provide resistance to Mediterranean marine bioinvasions? A seaweed example" can be found in the journal Biological Invasions, 13(6): 1397-1408, June 2011.