Effects of Nitrite Exposure on Rabbitfish

Lucy Towers
22 December 2014, at 12:00am

Nitrite is toxic to fishes and is often encountered in recirculation aquaculture systems. Accordingly, the nitrite tolerance of potential aquaculture candidates needs to be assessed before the fish can be farmed in land-based recirculation systems. In the present work, Patrick Saoud et al, American University of Beirut, Lebanon, studied the susceptibility of the marbled rabbitfish to nitrite.

As locations suitable for aquaculture become scarcer and more costly and diseases more prevalent, modern aquaculture facilities are opting for intensive and biosecure rearing systems, mostly Recirculation Aquaculture Systems (RAS).

Intensive aquaculture could provide greater economic profits but intensification of fish culture frequently leads to increased loads of nitrogenous and other toxic metabolites, resulting in water quality deterioration. One of the toxic nitrogenous wastes often encountered in aquaculture systems is nitrite (NO2 ¯) which often reaches toxic levels in intensive RAS. In most intensive marine fish tank culture, some nitrite is tolerated as it is difficult to maintain a nitrite-free RAS. Consequently, aquaculturists need to understand the tolerance of the organism they are farming to chronic exposure to low concentrations of nitrite.

Nitrite is an intermediate product formed by bacterial nitrification of ammonia. Nitrite in the water competes with chloride on the chloride-bicarbonate exchanger present in the apical membranes of chloride cells of fish gills. Nitrite also competes with chloride for transfer across erythrocyte membranes leading to the oxidation of hemoglobin to met-hemoglobin. Consequently, excessive nitrite levels in culture systems can cause depressed growth, increased susceptibility to disease, and eventual mortality. However, this competition with chloride decreases the detrimental effects of nitrite in marine waters and makes nitrite more dangerous in freshwater aquaculture.

Acute and chronic toxicities of nitrite have been extensively studied in freshwater species such as rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss, Siberian sturgeon Acipenser baerii, Brandt, matrinxã Brycon cephalus, tambaqui Colossoma macropomum, Walleye Sander vitreus, mrigal carp Cirrhinus mrigala, European eel Anguilla anguilla, common carp Cyprinus carpio L., and silver perch Bidyanus bidyanus. Additionally, a few studies have evaluated responses of marine fish such as pompano Trachinotus marginatus, silver sea bream Sparus sarba, dark-banded rockfish, Sebastes inermis, Atlantic cod Gadus morhua, flounder Platichthys flesus, and cobia Rachycentron canadum [20] to ambient nitrite, but results vary greatly among species. Thus, we cannot use conclusions from previous work to estimate rabbitfish S. rivulatus tolerance to environmental nitrite.

Fish gills are multifunctional organs needed for respiration, osmoregulation, acid-base balance and nitrogenous excretion. The large surface area and direct continuous contact with the surrounding water make the gills the first target to waterborne chemicals. Pollutants enter the organism through the gills and exert their primary toxic effects on the bronchial epithelium. Thus, morphological changes in fish gills are among the most commonly recognized responses to environmental stressors and are indicative of physical and chemical stress in marine as well as freshwater habitats. Histopathological changes in gills such as epithelial lifting, hypertrophy, hyperplasia, epithelial necrosis, edema, and fusion of secondary lamellae are the major effects reported in fish exposed to various types of pollutants and toxic substances. There are presently no published reports on the effects of ambient nitrite on rabbitfish gills.

Marbled rabbitfish Siganus rivulatus is a euryhaline, herbivorous marine fish widely distributed along the Eastern Mediterranean and East Indian Ocean. This teleost is a valuable fishery species that is relatively easy to farm and thus considered of great potential for warm-water aquaculture diversification. However, for the rabbitfish aquaculture industry to succeed, tolerance to metabolites that the fish will be exposed to has to be understood. The present work was performed to evaluate the tolerance of marbled rabbitfish to nitrite exposure. We determined acute nitrite tolerance of juvenile rabbitfish by establishing 96-h LC50 of NO2-N. We then evaluated the effects of chronic exposure of S. rivulatus to nitrite on survival, growth performance, hematological and biochemical parameters. Finally, we determined levels of total hemoglobin and methemoglobin in the fish upon chronic nitrite exposure.


Acute nitrite exposure (96h LC50)

The NO2-N 96 h LC50 of S. rivulatus juveniles was 105 mg l-1 with 95% confidence limits between 97.8 and 114.3 mg l-1. All fish survived for 96 h in the treatments containing nitrite concentrations from 0 to 60 mg l-1. Some mortality was observed in treatments containing nitrite concentrations from 70 to 100 mg l-1 (Figure 1). Mortalities increased significantly at 110 mg l-1 where half of the fish were dead after a 96 h exposure. Almost all fish in treatments 120 and 130 mg l-1 NO2-N were dead at 96 h.

Mortality of rabbitfish juveniles after a 24 hour exposure was 0% for nitrite concentrations ranging from 0 to 120 mg l-1, and was only 2% at 130 mg l-1. After 48 h of nitrite exposure, mortality of juveniles was 0% for nitrite-N concentrations of 0 to 80 mg l-1, and increased with nitrite-N increase between 90 and 130 mg l-1. Significant differences among treatments started appearing after 48 h of exposure and became more apparent with time. After 96 h of exposure, most of the fish had died in 120 and 130 mg l-1 NO2-N (Figure 1). Fish exposed to nitrite concentrations ranging from 0 to 70 mg l-1, exhibited no abnormal behavior. Fish swam normally with no loss of balance or orientation. However, at greater nitrite concentrations, fish exhibited erratic swimming, and were occasionally observed lying still at the bottom of the containers. At NO2-N concentrations of 110, 120 and 130 mg l-1, all fish were lethargic and dark in color, thus exhibiting usual signs of stress in marbled rabbitfish.

Chronic nitrite exposure

Growth and survival: All fish in treatment 50 mg l-1 NO2-N died by the end of the fourth week (Table 1). All fish at 0 mg l-1 NO2-N survived. Mortality was observed in treatments 10 and 20 mg l-1 NO2-N but results were not significantly different from the control. In treatments 30 and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N survival were 47.0% and 40.0% respectively, significantly less than in lower concentration treatments (Table 1). The final weight and final length of fish in treatment 0 mg l-1 were greater than final weight and final length of fish in all other treatments. There were no significant differences in final weight and final length among treatments 10, 20, 30 and 40 mg l-1 although a decreasing trend in growth was observed as nitrite concentration increased (Table 1).

Although final condition index (Kf) decreased as nitrite concentration increased, results were not significantly different from each other among treatments (Table 1). There were also no significant differences in initial Hepato-Somatic Index (HSI) or in final HSI among treatments (Table 1).

Hematological and biochemical parameters: Total Erythrocyte Count (TEC) decreased progressively with increasing nitrite concentrations (Table 2). Compared to the initial value (3.86×106 μl- 1), a significant reduction (P<0.05) in TECs was observed at all nitrite concentrations from 10 mg l-1 (2.86×106 μl-1) to 40 mg l-1 (1.67×106 μl-1) (Table 2). Hematocrit (Ht) values in treatments 20, 30, and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N were significantly less (P<0.05) than Ht values at 0 and 10 mg l-1 NO2-N (Table 2). Significantly lower total hemoglobin (Hb) levels were found in fish exposed to 10, 20, 30, and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N compared to the control (Table 2).

Total Leukocyte Count (TLC) of fish in treatments 10, 20 and 30 mg l-1 NO2-N were significantly greater than TLC in the control group (P<0.05) (Table 2). However, TLC in fish at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N was significantly less than TLC in other treatments (P<0.05). TLC in fish at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N was even less than TLC in control fish although the difference was not statistically significant (Table 2).

Average Total Plasma Protein (TPP) content in control fish was 3.92 g dl-1. A reduction in TPP was observed with increasing nitrite concentrations (Table 2). At 40 mg l-1 NO2-N, TPP was significantly less than in fish in all other treatments. There was no significant difference in TPP among all other treatments (Table 2). Lactate levels increased as nitrite concentrations increased, but there were no significant differences among treatments (Table 2).

Neutrophil numbers increased progressively with increasing nitrite concentrations. The proportion of neutrophils in the blood of fish at 20, 30, and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N were significantly greater than in the control (Table 3). The proportion at 30 mg l-1 NO2-N was greater than at 10 mg l-1 and the proportion at 40 mg l-1 was greater than the neutrophil proportion of the fish blood at all other treatments (Table 3). Eosinophil proportion in blood also increased with increasing ambient nitrite concentrations and in fish maintained at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N it was significantly different from all other treatments (Table 3).

Lymphocytes proportion in blood of control fish was 10.89%, increasing to 13.89% and 16.43% in blood of fish at 10 and 20 mg l-1 NO2-N respectively (Table 3). However, the differences were not significantly different from each other. In blood of fish maintained at 30 and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N, lymphocyte proportions increased significantly to reach 29.25 and 30.50% of WBCs, respectively (Table 3). Thrombocytes proportion in blood of control fish was 80.0% and decreased significantly as ambient nitrite increased. In blood of fish maintained at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N, thrombocytes comprised only 11% of total WBCs (Table 3). Monocytes proportion in blood increased with an increase in ambient nitrite concentrations but values were not significantly different among treatments (Table 3). No basophils were found in any of the hematological slides that were examined.

Histology: Gill preparations of control fish had normal gill architecture and typical structural organization of gill filaments (Figure 2). The structure of the lamellae observed was comparable to gills described by Gisbert et al. [7] and Kroupova et al. [6] for healthy fish. The gill arch was composed of healthy looking long gill filaments (primary lamellae) bearing distinct secondary lamellae on both sides and well separated with evident interlamellar space. Secondary lamellae were evenly arranged, running parallel to each other, and also showed clear interlamellar spaces.

Gill preparations of fish in 10 mg l-1 NO2-N revealed distinguishable deformations and apparent gill damage such as twisted uneven secondary lamellae, fusion and hyperplasia of secondary lamellae. Fish exposed to 20 mg l-1 nitrite nitrogen had dilations of central axes and infiltration of red blood cells with hyperplasia of spiked and shortened secondary lamellae. Fish exposed to 30 mg l-1 nitrite nitrogen hadblunt ended secondary lamellae with aneurysms, and hypertrophy and hyperplasia of epithelial cells (Figure 3).

Gills of fish exposed to 40 mg l-1 NO2-N revealed significant disorganization and twisting of secondary lamellae with severe hyperplasia leading to lamellar fusion. Additionally, aneurysms and vascular congestions of lamellae were observed. Fish exposed to 50 mg l-1 NO2-N exhibited complete loss of gill structure resulting from lysis at several points (Figure 4a and 4b). Gill alteration included irregular, twisted and curled secondary lamellae, and severe gill hypertrophy, hyperplasia, lamellar telangiectasia and ruptures of lamellar epithelia, and lamellar fusion.

Plasma nitrite and methemoglobin determination: Blood hemoglobin (total Hb) of the rabbitfish decreased as ambient nitrite increased. Significantly lesser total hemoglobin levels were found in fish exposed to 10, 20, 30, and 40 mg l-1N2-N compared to the control (Figure 5a). Moreover, the percentage of MetHb increased significantly in fish exposed to 30 and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N concentrations compared with controls, and reached proportions between 28.55 and 71.40% of the total Hb respectively (Figure 5b). Plasma nitrite concentration increased significantly with increasing aqueous nitrite concentrations (Figure 5c). At 0 mg l-1 ambient NO2-N, plasma nitrite was 0.05 mg l-1 and increased nearly ten-fold to 0.47 mg l-1 when fish were maintained at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N for 19 days.


Acute nitrite exposure (96 h LC50)

Results of the acute nitrite toxicity study indicated that S. rivulatus juveniles have a 96 h LC50 of 105 mg l-1 NO2-N. Fish challenged with excessive nitrite exhibited erratic swimming, disorientation and lack of balance within 48 h of exposure. Similar behavior was reported in cobia exposed to nitrite by Rodrigues et al. The impaired swimming performance is possibly because of increased MetHb in the blood that causes a decrease in O2 available to tissues thus limiting activity. Margiocco et al. found that nitrite concentrations in liver, brain, gills and muscles do not reach the same levels as in the blood, which suggests that blood is the primary target of nitrite toxicity and that in turn affects all the other organs by reducing oxygen delivery.

No data about the tolerance of marbled rabbitfish to nitrite is reported in the literature. However, when compared to various other marine species, S. rivulatus shows middle-of-range tolerance to nitritenitrogen. The flounder Paralichthys orbignyanus is the most sensitive marine fish on record with a 96 h LC50 of 30 mg l-1 NO2-N and the dark-banded rockfish Sebastes inermis is the least sensitive fish reported, with a 96 h LC50 of 700 mg l-1 NO2-N. Other species show intermediary toxicity: 85 mg l-1 NO2-N for red drum Sciaenops ocellatus  and 199 mg l-1 NO2-N for the marine pejerrey Odontesthes argentinensis. Tolerance of S. rivulatus to short-term nitrite exposure is closest to that of Siberian sturgeon Acipenser baeri having LC50 of 130 mg l-1 NO2-N . Although nitrite tolerance changes with age, our interest was in tolerance of juveniles because these are the age groups important to aquaculturists.

Chronic nitrite exposure

Survival and growth of juvenile marbled rabbitfish exposed to NO2-N concentrations of 10 to 40 mg l-1 over 56 days decreased as the nitrite concentration increased. However, nitrite uptake, toxicity, and effects vary among fish species and life stages, as well as with environmental conditions such as temperature, thus making comparison of toxicity values among studies difficult.

Although studies on long-term effects of aqueous nitrite on growth and survival of marine fish are relatively scarce, there are reports that increasing nitrite levels lead to net reductions in growth and/or survival of various fish species. Our results indicate growth suppression and mortality but these results were only significant at the greater nitrite concentrations (30 and 40 mg l-1 NO2-N ) used in the present experiment. A similar trend of reduction in growth of marine fish concomitant with increasing nitrite concentrations was reported by Siikavuopio and Saether working with juvenile cod Gadus morhua. However, growth suppression was not always correlated with increasing nitrite concentrations. Wedemeyer and Yasutake found no growth suppression of steelhead trout Salmo gairdneri exposed to low nitrite concentrations for six months. Similarly, Kamstra et al., observed no growth reduction in European eel Anguilla anguilla exposed to sub-lethal nitrite concentrations.

Finally, no significant differences in HSI among fish exposed to the various nitrite concentrations were observed in the present work. Similar results were observed by Deane and Woo working with the bream Sparus sarba. Apparently, although nitrite is partly detoxified by the liver of some fishes such as rainbow trout, most of the mitigation is performed by methemoglobin reductase in oxygenated RBCs, thus possibly sparing the liver. However, nitrite has been reported to cause some liver damage in various fishes. Huang and Chen suspected liver necrosis in eel Anguilla anguilla following exposure to very low levels of nitrite. Nitrite does not seem to have similar deleterious effects on rabbitfish livers as it has on livers of some other fishes.

A significant reduction in total erythrocyte count as observed in the present work was reported in various freshwater fishes and Park et al. reported a decrease in hemoglobin content with increasing nitrite concentrations in the marine dark-banded rockfish. Jensen suggested that significant changes in the blood parameters of fish caused by nitrite exposure, such as reduction in total erythrocyte count, total Hb concentration, and Ht levels, may be a consequence of passage of nitrite into the blood stream causing RBC hemolysis. The problems are further compounded because hemolysis results in efflux of RBC potassium, leading to RBC shrinkage and creating a situation of oxygen shortage in the fish.

Leukocytes are involved in the regulation of immunological functions and their numbers increase as fish respond to stressful conditions . Although some authors consider fish thrombocytes to be equivalent to platelets in mammals, we consider thrombocytes as complete white blood cells as suggested by Tavares-Dias and Oliveira. In the present study, TLC increased with increase in nitrite concentration up to 20 mg l-1 NO2-N then decreased at greater nitrite-N concentrations (30 and 40 mg l-1). Similar results were found in Cirrhinus mrigala (Ham) where TLC increased with increasing nitrite concentrations and then decreased with further exposure. Possibly, the excessive stress caused failure/exhaustion of leukopoiesis, resulting in reduction of TLC at higher nitrite concentrations. It is also possible that decreased oxygen content of the blood affected hemopoietic tissues such as the kidney.

Differential leukocyte counts of juvenile Siganus rivulatus in the present study showed an increase in the percentages of neutrophils, lymphocytes, monocytes, and eosinophils concomitant with an increase in nitrite concentrations. Such results are not surprising considering stress generally causes neutrophilia in fish. Moreover, Das et al. reported that lymphocyte and monocyte prevalence is affected by hypoxic stress. No basophils were observed in blood of fish in the present experiment. Apparently, such results are common in Mediterranean and Red Sea fishes. No basophils were found in blood of six Mediterranean fish species examined by Pavlidis et al. or in 50 species of fishes from the Red Sea.

Total plasma protein values of Siganus rivulatus showed a decreasing trend with increasing nitrite concentrations, with a significant reduction of TPP in fish maintained at 40 mg l-1 NO2-N results corroborate results observed in dark-banded rockfish Sebastes inermis, which when subjected to nitrite concentrations between 200- 700 mg l-1 NO2-N for 96 h portrayed a significant reduction in serum protein . Similarly, Das et al. reported significant decrease of serum protein level in C. mrigala following exposure to 4-10.4 mg l-1 nitrite.

Possibly, fish require extra energy to maintain metabolism when subjected to toxicant induced stress and requirement is met by increasing protein catabolism, thereby reducing plasma protein. In addition, hemolysis and removal of RBCs could cause a dilution of plasma which is also observed as a small reduction in plasma protein levels. The reduction in plasma protein in the present study, concomitant with increasing nitrite concentrations is probably a result of both protein catabolism and plasma dilution.

One effect of hypoxia on fish is an increase in lactate production. Woo and Chiu reported a significant increase in blood lactate of L. calcarifer exposed to various aqueous nitrite levels. Although in the present work no significant differences were observed among blood lactate levels of fish maintained at various nitrite levels, results do suggest an increase in blood lactate of fish reared in the 40 mg l-1 NO2-N waters compared to fish in other treatments. The fact that lactate increase was only observed at high nitrite levels suggests that there might be a threshold for oxygen content in the blood, below which lactate starts increasing. Similar observations of plasma lactate being only discernible in fish exposed to extremely high nitrite concentration were reported by Jensen et al. working with carp.

Histological changes in fish gills are among the most commonly recognized responses to environmental pollutants. In the present study, light micrographs of gills revealed that chronic exposure to nitrite resulted in distinguishable tissue deformations and apparent gill damage as compared to gills of fish not exposed to nitrite. These observations were similar to those of Bullock, Larmoyeaux and Piper, Takashima and Hibiya, and Fernandes et al.  to name but a few.

In several slides, epithelial lifting and lysis of some blood sinuses were observed. Epithelial lifting possibly served as a defense mechanism, because separation of lamellar epithelia increase the distance across which waterborne pollutants must diffuse to reach the bloodstream. However, as Peters et al. suggested, epithelial lifting causes an increased diffusion distance across the membrane reducing the gill’s functional surface area and capacity for efficient gas exchange.

The most characteristic features observed in nitrite exposed fish were lamellar aneurysms. The lamellar aneurysms are believed to result from the collapse of pillar cell systems and the breakdown of vascular integrity with a release of large quantities of blood that push the lamellar epithelium outward . In the present study, excessive nitrite caused severe histopathological alterations in the gills of Siganus rivulatus and may be the reason for the mortality observed. Fish exposed to lesser nitrite concentrations exhibited histological signs of stress but were able to survive.

Plasma nitrite and methemoglobin determination

Methemoglobin levels in siganid blood increased as environmental nitrite concentration increased. At an aqueous concentration of 40 mg l-1 NO2-N, blood methemoglobin reached an average of 71.4% of total hemoglobin. Similar observations are reported for sea bass Dicentrarchus labrax by Scarano et al. As the proportion of methemoglobin in the blood increased, the proportion of functional hemoglobin decreased but also the total amount of hemoglobin in the blood decreased. Such results are corroborated by Brown and Mcleay and Margiocco et al. suggesting that although anoxia resulting from methemoglobinemia is the primary mechanism of nitrite toxicity , nitrite also causes a decrease in total hemoglobin in the blood which compounds the problem.

However, this observation has not been reported in all fish species exposed to nitrite. Hemoglobin decrease was not observed in sea bass exposed 24 h to nitrite, and was not reported in channel catfish exposed 24 h to 5 mg l-1 NO2-N. Moreover, methemoglobinemia has been questioned as the sole mechanism of nitrite toxicity in fish. Regardless of the mode of action of environmental nitrite, the marbled rabbitfish is quite tolerant of nitrite if reared at a salinity of 35‰ making the species quite suitable for intensive aquaculture in recirculation systems.


The present work was funded by a grant from the Lebanese National Council for Scientific Research.

Further Reading

You can view the full report and list of authors by clicking here.

December 2014